Swinney says Scottish independence referendum could be held in 2028

Scottish Independence Referendum Possible by 2028, Says Swinney

First Minister John Swinney has suggested that a second independence referendum for Scotland might occur as early as 2028. During a BBC Scotland Debate Night event in Paisley Town Hall, he argued that holding a constitutional vote within two years is entirely feasible. The SNP leader emphasized that the people of Scotland deserve to determine their own future, though he acknowledged a “constitutional logjam” currently preventing progress.

Party Leaders Clash Over Independence and Governance

In the debate, various party leaders presented differing views. Ross Greer, co-leader of the Greens, stated that Scotland’s direction should be decided by its citizens, criticizing Westminster for blocking a second vote. Meanwhile, Labour’s Anas Sarwar insisted the upcoming election is about forming a government that addresses key challenges like the NHS and cost of living, not independence. Conservative leader Russell Findlay warned that breaking up the UK would be a “disaster” and urged Swinney to focus on his primary responsibilities.

“We’re not having one [referendum], this country has had enough of chaos,” said Health Secretary Wes Streeting to LBC.

Malcolm Offord, Reform UK’s Scottish representative, described another referendum as divisive but conceded it could be warranted if independence support rises to 60%. Alex Cole-Hamilton of the Liberal Democrats claimed he had not seriously considered a second vote, citing his attention on other priorities like education and the economy.

Key Issues Fuel Debate

Control over immigration and borders remains with the UK government, yet it has become a central topic in the Holyrood election campaign. Offord advocated for “cohesion” in Scottish communities, while Susan Aitken, Glasgow City Council leader, highlighted that the city hosts over 3,800 asylum seekers, stressing the strain on temporary housing. Greer countered that immigration is vital for the NHS and rural areas, calling Offord a “chancer” for opposing it.

“The problem is we do not have enough immigration to meet the needs of the country,” Greer asserted.

Swinney urged voters to give the SNP a clear mandate to take control of Scotland’s future, citing their previous majority in the 2014 referendum. He framed the debate as an opportunity to resolve longstanding issues, including the NHS and economic challenges. Sarwar, meanwhile, accused Offord of undermining national unity by targeting migrants.

Political Stances on Constitutional Change

While Swinney saw a second vote as a solution, others viewed it skeptically. Sarwar emphasized that the current election is about practical governance, not independence. Findlay, however, warned that a weak prime minister might approve the referendum, urging the SNP to “get on with the day job” and address Scotland’s worsening conditions. The discussion also touched on energy and public services, reflecting broader concerns across the political spectrum.