Here’s how the TV networks handled Trump’s highly unusual prime-time address

Here s how the TV networks covered Trump’s prime-time address

Here s how the TV networks handled President Donald Trump’s highly unusual prime-time address on Thursday night. Some major broadcast networks showed the speech live while others pointedly did not — a divide that highlighted Trump’s long record of making false claims and renewed discussion about the news media’s responsibilities. The White House took the rare step of formally asking the broadcast networks to take the speech live, setting up Trump to castigate those that opted not to. And Trump made network decision-making a central talking point in his speech.

Networks split on live coverage and fact-checking

He harshly criticized NBC and ABC for not preempting their prime-time shows for his address and said it “should mean a revocation of their licenses.” The two other major US broadcast networks, CBS and Fox, did air the unusual prime-time address. CBS surrounded the speech with fact-checking and context both before and immediately afterward, a practice sometimes called a “truth sandwich.” Still, Democratic Sen. Mark Warner criticized CBS while appearing on the network to rebut Trump’s address.

He told anchor Tony Dokoupil, “It’s incumbent on you and any responsible journalist to push back on these falsehoods.” Dokoupil pointed out that he had been doing exactly that. Dokoupil said, “We agree, you and I, that this is a vitally, vitally important topic, and the president has a terrible track record on it.” The CBS anchor channeled the prevailing view in TV newsrooms. Trump’s fixation on false claims about the 2020 election made Thursday night’s address a fraught event for every organization in the business of live news coverage.

It was challenging even for Fox News, the president’s favorite network. Many at the network were loath to hear Trump relitigate the election he lost, two Fox News sources told CNN on condition of anonymity. Some at Fox thought the topic was simply bad politics for the GOP, while others thought it was bad for business, given that Fox was consumed by litigation after amplifying the president’s election lies in 2020.

Ultimately, and unsurprisingly, Fox News showed the address live in full during Trump friend Sean Hannity’s hour, followed by a brief discussion between Hannity and White House correspondent Aishah Hasnie.

Hasnie noted Trump’s claims of compromised voting machines and said, “Fox News has not seen that evidence yet and is not in a position to evaluate the accuracy of the president’s statement and claims at this time.” Fox anchor Bret Baier, who led a special report on the Fox broadcast network, made a similar disclaimer afterward: “Fox News has not seen that documentation yet and is not in a position to assess the accuracy of the president’s statements tonight.” Overall, the address was taken seriously in partisan pro-Trump media circles, while it was treated skeptically everywhere else. On cable, MSNBC aired about 15 minutes of the speech, then cut away to unpack Trump’s claims.

Chris Hayes said reacting to the speech was “a little bit like trying to argue with, like, a raving crazy person standing next to you on the subway claiming they’re Jesus Christ.” CNN opted not to take the speech live, instead treating it like other presidential events that are monitored for news and scrutinized for accuracy. “We’ll be monitoring what the president says tonight, as we always do, but aren’t taking it live, given the president has a well-documented history of saying blatantly false things about elections,” anchor Kaitlan Collins told viewers. Collins and correspondent Evan Perez showed clips from the speech with a heavy amount of reality-checking.

A group of CNN journalists in the DC newsroom was shown on camera reviewing the newly declassified documents and assessing Trump’s claims. CNN also streamed the speech live on its website, accompanied by real-time analysis from correspondents and experts. NBC and ABC took a similar approach by streaming the speech and then reporting on its contents.

Both broadcast networks interrupted prime time for brief special reports after Trump finished speaking. NBC’s Hallie Jackson said the information Trump presented was “largely not new.” Earlier on Thursday, network executives were locked in hours-long meetings about how to handle the address. The internal debates centered on two competing interests: the traditional newsworthiness of a presidential address and the risks of giving Trump an unfiltered platform for his election denialism.

But, as an executive at one of the networks remarked, “It’s not 1974 anymore. There are lots of ways to cover the news.” And most of the networks landed somewhere in the middle, acknowledging the address without taking Trump at face value. There were fact-checks and critiques galore. But the raw speech was also widely available, from YouTube to the White House’s own website. Dokoupil began the CBS special report by saying that “much of what the president has said before has been wrong.”